Scheppers reax

Talked to a lot of folks today and news of the Scheppers injury was topic No. 1. The reaction pretty much came in one of two ways:

1. I’ve never heard of an injury like this. Not from pitching, anyway.
2. I wonder if this is the whole story.

Now, the scouting industry is skeptical by nature, and for good reason. As one scout told me, he’s seen a player sit out with a reported groin strain only to need elbow surgery a week later (who knew the groin and elbow were connected like that???). The point is that people don’t always tell the truth about injuries. Is the “stress fracture” just masking something else, like a torn labrum or rotator cuff? I don’t know if that’s true, but there is some concern out there that there’s more going on here.

Another worry was if Scheppers hurt the shoulder doing something off the field. No one, and I mean no one, had ever heard of a pitcher getting a stress fracture in the shoulder from pitching. That doesn’t mean it can’t happen — you’ll hear about elbow stress fractures from hard throwers like Bobby Jenks from time to time — but this would mark the first time many baseball lifers had ever seen anything like this. So even if it is just a stress fracture, there has to be concern over how a guy manages to do that while pitching.

I’m curious where people think he’ll end up going when all is said and done (leave your thoughts in comments). The main choices seem to be:

1. Back to school, like Kent State’s Chris Carpenter last year.
2. Much later in the draft, but he signs anyway because he really wants to play pro ball.
3. To a team with lots o’ resources near the back of the first round, a team that can afford to wait if it’s a lengthier injury recovery period than expected and can even afford if the pick never pans out.

My vote is for No. 3. Without any inside info on this one, I say the Yankees take him and let him hang out with Andrew Brackman. They can form one of the greatest rehabbing potential future rotation duos of all time.


Well depending on the injury, I think going back to school would be the best bet for him. He would have a chance to improve his draft stock to perhaps what it once was. I just don’t see how he will be drafted high (1st round) with that many questions surrounding him and even if he was, they wouldn’t offer more then slot. Now I suppose if he just wants to play pro ball and is drafted high enough that slot is still substantial, he could sign.

Full disclosure: I am a die hard Yankees fan.

I would love for the Yankees to take him at 28 if I knew for sure that it was a stress fracture, because I believe that it is a fluky injury that doesn’t sound like it would have a long term effect, but drafting a pitcher with a torn labrum or rotator cuff is a huge waste.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: